5F6A Noise problem
Moderators: pompeiisneaks, Colossal
5F6A Noise problem
Hi Gents
I've been gigging my Bassman build for the last year and a half (after you good people helped me troubleshoot it). But recently she's developed a problem which has reached the point where I have had to stop playing her and I am at my wits end trying to sort it out.
The issue is this - originally, after an hour or so the amp would make "rustling sounds". I though it was a problem with a dodgy lead but over time the problem has been occurring more and more. Then I started getting "gunshot" sounds - in low light every time the sounds happen the power tubes would flash blue. I swapped the power tubes to a new pair, rebiased and everything was fine. For a little while.......
After a couple more gigs the noises started again, usually after an hour of being switched on. I assumed this was a thermal issue and have been checking for burnt out resistors or caps. Anything that looked even slightly dodgy was replaced. It then reached the point where the amp would make the noises almost immediately it was powered up and the tubes reached temperature. I've swapped out the preamp tubes to no avail. If I pull the PI tube the noises stop. If I replace the PI and pull V2 it stops, replacing the PI and V2 but removing V1and the noises re-occur.
I've checked the voltages and everything is within spec. I've replaced most of the electrolytics and the voltage dropping resistors with new and there's no change.
Is there anything obvious I am missing? Is it a transformer that is going faulty? I'm pulling my hair out - if it was a new build I would understand it but it is an amp that has been performing faithfully for 18 months.
Thanks in advance,
Phil
I've been gigging my Bassman build for the last year and a half (after you good people helped me troubleshoot it). But recently she's developed a problem which has reached the point where I have had to stop playing her and I am at my wits end trying to sort it out.
The issue is this - originally, after an hour or so the amp would make "rustling sounds". I though it was a problem with a dodgy lead but over time the problem has been occurring more and more. Then I started getting "gunshot" sounds - in low light every time the sounds happen the power tubes would flash blue. I swapped the power tubes to a new pair, rebiased and everything was fine. For a little while.......
After a couple more gigs the noises started again, usually after an hour of being switched on. I assumed this was a thermal issue and have been checking for burnt out resistors or caps. Anything that looked even slightly dodgy was replaced. It then reached the point where the amp would make the noises almost immediately it was powered up and the tubes reached temperature. I've swapped out the preamp tubes to no avail. If I pull the PI tube the noises stop. If I replace the PI and pull V2 it stops, replacing the PI and V2 but removing V1and the noises re-occur.
I've checked the voltages and everything is within spec. I've replaced most of the electrolytics and the voltage dropping resistors with new and there's no change.
Is there anything obvious I am missing? Is it a transformer that is going faulty? I'm pulling my hair out - if it was a new build I would understand it but it is an amp that has been performing faithfully for 18 months.
Thanks in advance,
Phil
-
- Posts: 4570
- Joined: Fri Jan 24, 2014 3:01 pm
- Location: 1/3rd the way out one of the arms of the Milkyway.
Re: 5F6A Noise problem
I have just had a popping issue like this with a Marshall major and it was preamp tube socket and tube pin related.
You did not say how old the amp was but it would not hurt to replace all of the plate load resistors in the preamp section and also how old are the filters?
You did not say how old the amp was but it would not hurt to replace all of the plate load resistors in the preamp section and also how old are the filters?
When I die, I want to go like my Grandfather did, peacefully in his sleep.
Not screaming like the passengers in his car!
Cutting out a man's tongue does not mean he’s a liar, but it does show that you fear the truth he might speak about you!
Not screaming like the passengers in his car!
Cutting out a man's tongue does not mean he’s a liar, but it does show that you fear the truth he might speak about you!
Re: 5F6A Noise problem
Thanks Steve - she was built from scratch, so it's all 18 months old. I've replaced the plate resistors with new, also some of the electrolytics. I'm going to do the bias electro's next and see - I've cleaned the tube sockets and re-tensioned the power tubes sockets. I'll do the preamp ones in the morning and see if that helps.
Cheers
Phil
Cheers
Phil
- Milkmansound
- Posts: 470
- Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 6:55 pm
- Contact:
Re: 5F6A Noise problem
Try to isolate which gain stage it's from. I've had mica caps cause that by leaking, tubes cause it, and also plate load resistors. Could be cathode resistors too.
Heat the amp up, get the noise to start, and then start grounding out the low voltage sides of coupling caps until it's gone. Once you have the gain stage nailed down, there's only 3-4 parts that could be responsible and then your work is much easier!
Heat the amp up, get the noise to start, and then start grounding out the low voltage sides of coupling caps until it's gone. Once you have the gain stage nailed down, there's only 3-4 parts that could be responsible and then your work is much easier!
Re: 5F6A Noise problem
Thanks for the help, Gents. If I pull V2 the noise stops - I've chopsticked everything and the only noise I get is when I tap the plate wire to pin 2 of V2. I've reflowed the joints and swapped out most of the caps for new - I reckon it could be the tube socket. Is it worth replacing this or should I check something else first?
Cheers
Phil
Cheers
Phil
-
- Posts: 1069
- Joined: Tue Jul 02, 2013 12:51 am
- Location: East Texas (Yee Yee!)
Re: 5F6A Noise problem
If the problem is the tube socket, then wiggling the tube in the socket while it is on should make the noise you are describing.
"It's like what Lenin said... you look for the person who will benefit, and, uh, uh..."
Re: 5F6A Noise problem
If I wiggle the tube it doesn't make a noise - I'm thinking it may be an electro on the way out. I have new caps and a new socket on their way - hopefully with these parts swapped out it should be resolved. Hopefully!
Re: 5F6A Noise problem
So it seems like the problem is V2. What voltages have you got there? There's a cathode follower so it may be a problem with the H-K voltage limit. A lot of modern tubes hate being used in that position.
Re: 5F6A Noise problem
Pin 1, 7 and 8 I get 180V, 334v on pin 6. I've swapped half a dozen tubes in there with no change.
Re: 5F6A Noise problem
Latest update....
Have replaced all the electrolytics in the amp with new and replaced the tube socket at V2. No change...still the same noises blue flashes from the power tubes All the voltages seem fine - as I have previously said, I've been gigging the amp for over a year so its not like she's a new build in need of trouble shooting.
Final thing I can think to check - could the volume pots need replacing? I've sprayed them with cleaner and they work smoothly with no crackling. But they are the final stage before V2. Or the 270K mixer resistors?
I notice that the jewel light flickers and varies in brightness all the time the amp is on - could this be helpful in tracking down my gremlins or is it just a bulb on the way out?
Cheers
Phil
Have replaced all the electrolytics in the amp with new and replaced the tube socket at V2. No change...still the same noises blue flashes from the power tubes All the voltages seem fine - as I have previously said, I've been gigging the amp for over a year so its not like she's a new build in need of trouble shooting.
Final thing I can think to check - could the volume pots need replacing? I've sprayed them with cleaner and they work smoothly with no crackling. But they are the final stage before V2. Or the 270K mixer resistors?
I notice that the jewel light flickers and varies in brightness all the time the amp is on - could this be helpful in tracking down my gremlins or is it just a bulb on the way out?
Cheers
Phil
Re: 5F6A Noise problem
Is the heater voltage steady, or is it jumping around in sync with the light's flickering? (It's the normal Fender 6 volt indicator light connected to the heaters, correct?)
Re: 5F6A Noise problem
Yes, normal Fender 6V heaters. Just checked and the voltage is steady, even when making the noise. So that's a good thing, yes?
Re: 5F6A Noise problem
I unsoldered the wire to pin 2 (the grid, right?) of V2 and still the amp would make the noise after it warmed up. I pull V2 and it stops - what should I be looking for next? I gotta be close
Cheers
Phil
Cheers
Phil
- JazzGuitarGimp
- Posts: 2355
- Joined: Mon Jul 23, 2012 4:54 pm
- Location: Northern CA
Re: 5F6A Noise problem
Have you tried a different tube at V2?
Lou Rossi Designs
Printed Circuit Design & Layout,
and Schematic Capture
Printed Circuit Design & Layout,
and Schematic Capture
Re: 5F6A Noise problem
Yeah, a bunch of trusted ones - still no change.