PI Bias Feed Resistors
Moderators: pompeiisneaks, Colossal
-
- Posts: 178
- Joined: Wed May 31, 2017 11:11 pm
PI Bias Feed Resistors
Not sure if that's the correct term for these. Grid leak/bias feed/bias splitters... the resistors on the output of the phase inverter right before the (usually) 5.6K grids on the power tubes.
Let's take a typical 50-watt 2204/JCM800 circuit. The PI has 0.022uF output coupling caps with 220K bias feed resistors, 5.6K grid stoppers on the power tubes.
What does changing the value of these resistors do to the sound of the amp? I know lowering them was commonly done on Marshalls shipped to the US with 6550s instead of EL34s. And that a lower value can help with tube longevity in the case a runaway with modern tubes. But does the value affect the actual sound of the amp?
Let's say going from 220K down to 180K, 150K, 120K, 110K. EL34s in each case.
Let's take a typical 50-watt 2204/JCM800 circuit. The PI has 0.022uF output coupling caps with 220K bias feed resistors, 5.6K grid stoppers on the power tubes.
What does changing the value of these resistors do to the sound of the amp? I know lowering them was commonly done on Marshalls shipped to the US with 6550s instead of EL34s. And that a lower value can help with tube longevity in the case a runaway with modern tubes. But does the value affect the actual sound of the amp?
Let's say going from 220K down to 180K, 150K, 120K, 110K. EL34s in each case.
- martin manning
- Posts: 13276
- Joined: Sun Jul 06, 2008 12:43 am
- Location: 39°06' N 84°30' W
Re: PI Bias Feed Resistors
The coupling cap and the grid leak resistor make a high-pass filter, so if you halve the resistor value you will raise the -3dB corner point one octave, reducing the bass response. The corner point frequency is given by fo = 1/(2 Pi R C), where R is the sum of the grid leak and the Zo of the PI, which is typically 40-50k. Doubling the coupling cap value would lower the corner point back to where it was. Reducing the value of the grid leak resistor will also load the PI, rotating the AC load line clockwise, which will change its clipping characteristics.
-
- Posts: 178
- Joined: Wed May 31, 2017 11:11 pm
Re: PI Bias Feed Resistors
Thanks for the info. I understand some of what you said lol. A lot of it is above my level of knowledge here.martin manning wrote: ↑Mon Jul 24, 2017 9:52 pm The coupling cap and the grid leak resistor make a high-pass filter, so if you halve the resistor value you will raise the -3dB corner point one octave, reducing the bass response. The corner point frequency is given by fo = 1/(2 Pi R C), where R is the sum of the grid leak and the Zo of the PI, which is typically 40-50k. Doubling the coupling cap value would lower the corner point back to where it was. Reducing the value of the grid leak resistor will also load the PI, rotating the AC load line clockwise, which will change its clipping characteristics.
I understand the part about halving the resistor value = raising bass cutoff one octave (thus reducing bass response).
What is "Zo" ? Is that the impedance of the stage?
So .022uF caps + 220K resistors is about the same as 0.047uF caps and 110K resistors? Is there any other difference in terms of feel between the two or is it really all just a numbers thing? What I mean is if the effect difference on paper is basically zero, is there some other effect that isn't represented by the math?
The part I don't understand is: "Reducing the value of the grid leak resistor will also load the PI, rotating the AC load line clockwise, which will change its clipping characteristics."
What's the net sonic effect of this? Reducing the resistor value makes the PI distort less?
- martin manning
- Posts: 13276
- Joined: Sun Jul 06, 2008 12:43 am
- Location: 39°06' N 84°30' W
Re: PI Bias Feed Resistors
Yes 0.022 and 220k is about like 0.047 and 110k, and Zo is the output impedance of the PI. The grid leak resistors are the load seen by the PI, so just as changing speaker impedance affects the load seen by the power tubes. I don't think there will be much difference in the PI distortion, but you will lower the PI gain and reduce the drive into the power tubes.
-
- Posts: 178
- Joined: Wed May 31, 2017 11:11 pm
Re: PI Bias Feed Resistors
Great, thank you for the help!martin manning wrote: ↑Tue Jul 25, 2017 1:14 am Yes 0.022 and 220k is about like 0.047 and 110k, and Zo is the output impedance of the PI. The grid leak resistors are the load seen by the PI, so just as changing speaker impedance affects the load seen by the power tubes. I don't think there will be much difference in the PI distortion, but you will lower the PI gain and reduce the drive into the power tubes.
Re: PI Bias Feed Resistors
A couple additional points to keep in mind:
- different tube types have different limiting values for the grid leak resistance.
- the limiting value is typically lower for fixed bias than for cathode bias.
So, for example, a JJ 6V6S in fixed bias has a limiting value of 100k, whereas the limiting value for an EL34 (fixed bias) is usually ~250k (if I recall correctly)...
- different tube types have different limiting values for the grid leak resistance.
- the limiting value is typically lower for fixed bias than for cathode bias.
So, for example, a JJ 6V6S in fixed bias has a limiting value of 100k, whereas the limiting value for an EL34 (fixed bias) is usually ~250k (if I recall correctly)...
-
- Posts: 178
- Joined: Wed May 31, 2017 11:11 pm
Re: PI Bias Feed Resistors
Yup, that I do know thanks No plans on going higher than 220K on the board. Typically 5.6K grids stoppers on the EL34s. I don't think too many people go higher than the ubiquitous 220K value. But I've certainly seen lower. Mostly 150K in the case of 6550-equipped amps.V2 wrote: ↑Tue Jul 25, 2017 4:01 pm A couple additional points to keep in mind:
- different tube types have different limiting values for the grid leak resistance.
- the limiting value is typically lower for fixed bias than for cathode bias.
So, for example, a JJ 6V6S in fixed bias has a limiting value of 100k, whereas the limiting value for an EL34 (fixed bias) is usually ~250k (if I recall correctly)...
The one I just built, I used 150K. This next one, I'll try 120K. I've been playing around with the ampbooks calculator, which is very handy. So I can tune the bass cutoff response with the caps. And I can use the PI gain calculator to see how much gain is reduced in the PI. So really, you could theoretically find a different resistor/cap combo that gives the same bass cutoff, but buy lowering the resistors, you've reduced the PI's gain. So it's a neat balancing act it seems.
Re: PI Bias Feed Resistors
Surprisingly it's 500k for EL34, or at least it should be http://www.mif.pg.gda.pl/homepages/fran ... e/EL34.pdf
My band:- http://www.youtube.com/user/RedwingBand
Re: PI Bias Feed Resistors
On fixed bias amps, the bias feed resistors are only part of the total grid leak resistance. The resistance in the bias power supply is added to the value of these bias feed resistors:
http://valvewizard.co.uk/bias.html
Which is (I think) why things look like they are different for fixed bias versus cathode bias. Really they are not. The tube always has the same max grid leak resistance (from the data sheet). But the path to ground on a fixed bias setup passes through more than one resistor.
Mike
http://valvewizard.co.uk/bias.html
Which is (I think) why things look like they are different for fixed bias versus cathode bias. Really they are not. The tube always has the same max grid leak resistance (from the data sheet). But the path to ground on a fixed bias setup passes through more than one resistor.
Mike
Re: PI Bias Feed Resistors
The limiting value of resistance g1 - k surely includes the bias supply, in the case of fixed bias; usually the bias supply resistive impedance is fairly low and may only add 10 to 20% on to the grid leak values.
And it must also include resistance added by bias vary trem arrangements.
And grid stoppers.
It's the total effective resistance between g1 and k.
Any resistance that is common to more than one tube will have its effective value multiplied by the number of tubes sharing it.
The limit is probably higher for cathode bias because of its self regulating nature, which will act to counteract positive grid current reducing the effective bias voltage; in fixed bias, that doesnt happen, hence any voltage created by positive grid current has to be limited by the g1-k resistance value..
And it must also include resistance added by bias vary trem arrangements.
And grid stoppers.
It's the total effective resistance between g1 and k.
Any resistance that is common to more than one tube will have its effective value multiplied by the number of tubes sharing it.
The limit is probably higher for cathode bias because of its self regulating nature, which will act to counteract positive grid current reducing the effective bias voltage; in fixed bias, that doesnt happen, hence any voltage created by positive grid current has to be limited by the g1-k resistance value..
My band:- http://www.youtube.com/user/RedwingBand