Big rehash - Strat into Dumble - what really works

Overdrive Special, Steel String Singer, Dumbleland, Odyssey, Winterland, etc. -
Members Only

Moderators: pompeiisneaks, Colossal

Post Reply
User avatar
rogb
Posts: 1089
Joined: Fri Apr 02, 2010 9:56 am
Location: London, England

Re: Big rehash - Strat into Dumble - what really works

Post by rogb »

I'm always interested to hear what Tony has to say.
I had tried the 250K/350K Level/ trim once before but not with the low plate config.

I dropped the parts in and gave it a run through with HB and Scs.

Nope, not for me, too much low/mid for my ears.

Went back to the 100K/100K and straight away could dial in the tones I liked.
It's always worth a try for anybody that thinks their sound needs beefing up.
vibratoking
Posts: 2640
Joined: Tue Nov 10, 2009 9:55 pm
Location: Colorado Springs, CO

Re: Big rehash - Strat into Dumble - what really works

Post by vibratoking »

Thanks for all the input guys, everyone. You guys make this a great place.

It's coincidental that I was running some sims on the 123 preamp/ tonestack, at the same time Tony posted about 123's OD trimmer. I'll give that a try, but right now I am focused on the clean preamp. Then I'll move to the OD...one thing at a time.

It is interesting that the sims show that 123s frequency response attenuates much of the bass and low mids compared to the Skyliner. Pretty close to what I was doing with the mid cap and slope resistor, just a different implementation. It makes me think that I am on the right track. From 123, one can imagine that HAD must have come to a similar conclusion - that the strat sound is compromised due to the congestion in lows and low mids. I'll post some sim results after I get some of this sorted out so that others can see the differences. They are quite significant. So thanks to mhartman for mentioning and posting the 123 schematic. The trick will be to keep the great HB performance while also improving the SC's.

I'll post my results when I have more time to investigate.
User avatar
alvarezh
Posts: 461
Joined: Thu Oct 18, 2007 11:11 am
Location: Santo Domingo, D.R.

Re: Big rehash - Strat into Dumble - what really works

Post by alvarezh »

@Tony, thank you for the tip.

On the layout of #124 done by Martin and you, the 10uF bypass caps are on the clean, not on the OD as you just stated.

@Vibrato, nice topic, thanks for all the research.

All the best to both.
Horacio

Play in tune and B#!
talbany
Posts: 4679
Joined: Tue Mar 28, 2006 5:03 am
Location: Dumbleland

Re: Big rehash - Strat into Dumble - what really works

Post by talbany »

Nope, not for me, too much low/mid for my ears.
Rogb
Here is how I approach it!!...EACH AMP IS DIFFERENT
I always use 100k OD trimmer..Lifting this and Level (or Drive) in most of the amps I've built is too much for humbuckers!
If I want to add just a touch of low mids I start at the opposite end and work back.. level control 250k
If I want more (at gig volume) I'll lift the Drive!!
This is usually plenty for me!!..Especially with a high plate..Be careful not to add too much and congest the OD tone as this will hamper the amps ability to sing..You want just enough so that the singles snarls at you..:twisted:

Vibro
Instead of lifting the OD trimmer place it on the back of the amp as Strat's for me could always use a bump up in signal here!!
FWIW..High plates for Strats IMO sounds best in OD.. But for Clean I prefer the low Plates..I live with it..YMMV!!!!
I'll post some sim results after I get some of this sorted out so that others can see the differences
Here is some discussions and calculations (3db knee) on this matter
http://ampgarage.com/forum/viewtopic.ph ... 250k+drive
I use my ears here!!
On the layout of #124 done by Martin and you, the 10uF bypass caps are on the clean, not on the OD as you just stated.
Just turned 50..Looks like my memory is slipping..:wink:

Again Good Luck!!

Tony
" The psychics on my bench is the same as Dumble'"
User avatar
rogb
Posts: 1089
Joined: Fri Apr 02, 2010 9:56 am
Location: London, England

Re: Big rehash - Strat into Dumble - what really works

Post by rogb »

talbany wrote:
Nope, not for me, too much low/mid for my ears.
Rogb
Here is how I approach it!!...EACH AMP IS DIFFERENT
I always use 100k OD trimmer..Lifting this and Level (or Drive) in most of the amps I've built is too much for humbuckers!
If I want to add just a touch of low mids I start at the opposite end and work back.. level control 250k
If I want more (at gig volume) I'll lift the Drive!!
This is usually plenty for me!!..Especially with a high plate..Be careful not to add too much and congest the OD tone as this will hamper the amps ability to sing..You want just enough so that the singles snarls at you..:twisted:

Vibro
Instead of lifting the OD trimmer place it on the back of the amp as Strat's for me could always use a bump up in signal here!!
FWIW..High plates for Strats IMO sounds best in OD.. But for Clean I prefer the low Plates..I live with it..YMMV!!!!
I'll post some sim results after I get some of this sorted out so that others can see the differences
Here is some discussions and calculations (3db knee) on this matter
http://ampgarage.com/forum/viewtopic.ph ... 250k+drive
On the layout of #124 done by Martin and you, the 10uF bypass caps are on the clean, not on the OD as you just stated.
Just turned 50..Looks like my memory is slipping..:wink:

Again Good Luck!!

Tony
Thanks Tony, straight away, it felt congested and stopped singing, exactly like you wrote! Obviously way too much for my guitars and this amp
I'll pop the 250K Level back in and see how she goes.
Mines a 50w so hasn't the girthiness of the 100w. I think just a little more of the low/mid without losing the snarl and sing will be perfect.
I find I'm just rolling off a little on the guitar tone to "cream" things up.
I play a lot with keys and sax as well as show off bass players, so finding a space in the spectrum is really important.
talbany
Posts: 4679
Joined: Tue Mar 28, 2006 5:03 am
Location: Dumbleland

Re: Big rehash - Strat into Dumble - what really works

Post by talbany »

rogb wrote:
talbany wrote:
Nope, not for me, too much low/mid for my ears.
Rogb
Here is how I approach it!!...EACH AMP IS DIFFERENT
I always use 100k OD trimmer..Lifting this and Level (or Drive) in most of the amps I've built is too much for humbuckers!
If I want to add just a touch of low mids I start at the opposite end and work back.. level control 250k
If I want more (at gig volume) I'll lift the Drive!!
This is usually plenty for me!!..Especially with a high plate..Be careful not to add too much and congest the OD tone as this will hamper the amps ability to sing..You want just enough so that the singles snarls at you..:twisted:

Vibro
Instead of lifting the OD trimmer place it on the back of the amp as Strat's for me could always use a bump up in signal here!!
FWIW..High plates for Strats IMO sounds best in OD.. But for Clean I prefer the low Plates..I live with it..YMMV!!!!
I'll post some sim results after I get some of this sorted out so that others can see the differences
Here is some discussions and calculations (3db knee) on this matter
http://ampgarage.com/forum/viewtopic.ph ... 250k+drive
On the layout of #124 done by Martin and you, the 10uF bypass caps are on the clean, not on the OD as you just stated.
Just turned 50..Looks like my memory is slipping..:wink:

Again Good Luck!!

Tony
Thanks Tony, straight away, it felt congested and stopped singing, exactly like you wrote! Obviously way too much for my guitars and this amp
I'll pop the 250K Level back in and see how she goes.
Mines a 50w so hasn't the girthiness of the 100w. I think just a little more of the low/mid without losing the snarl and sing will be perfect.
I find I'm just rolling off a little on the guitar tone to "cream" things up.
I play a lot with keys and sax as well as show off bass players, so finding a space in the spectrum is really important.
Sounds like you would be happier with a 100W
FWIW..The low mids that the 100w gives you will always for me trump tweaking the pot values in a 50w..But maybe it will help you better find your spot in the mix!!

Good Luck!!
Tony
" The psychics on my bench is the same as Dumble'"
Max
Posts: 1550
Joined: Wed May 31, 2006 6:08 pm

Re: Big rehash - Strat into Dumble - what really works

Post by Max »

talbany wrote: ... place it ... [OD trimmer] ... on the back of the amp ...
You'll find the trigger control on the back of some of the original ODS amps, too. Another obvious option would be placing it on the front - perhaps in combination with the h. f. taper control (#0121 with concentric pots e. g.: http://www.maverick-music.com/wp-conten ... 21_005.jpg - planned holes on the back: http://www.maverick-music.com/wp-conten ... 21_013.jpg)
User avatar
rogb
Posts: 1089
Joined: Fri Apr 02, 2010 9:56 am
Location: London, England

Re: Big rehash - Strat into Dumble - what really works

Post by rogb »

talbany wrote:
rogb wrote:
talbany wrote: Rogb
Here is how I approach it!!...EACH AMP IS DIFFERENT
I always use 100k OD trimmer..Lifting this and Level (or Drive) in most of the amps I've built is too much for humbuckers!
If I want to add just a touch of low mids I start at the opposite end and work back.. level control 250k
If I want more (at gig volume) I'll lift the Drive!!
This is usually plenty for me!!..Especially with a high plate..Be careful not to add too much and congest the OD tone as this will hamper the amps ability to sing..You want just enough so that the singles snarls at you..:twisted:

Vibro
Instead of lifting the OD trimmer place it on the back of the amp as Strat's for me could always use a bump up in signal here!!
FWIW..High plates for Strats IMO sounds best in OD.. But for Clean I prefer the low Plates..I live with it..YMMV!!!!
Here is some discussions and calculations (3db knee) on this matter
http://ampgarage.com/forum/viewtopic.ph ... 250k+drive
Just turned 50..Looks like my memory is slipping..:wink:

Again Good Luck!!

Tony
Thanks Tony, straight away, it felt congested and stopped singing, exactly like you wrote! Obviously way too much for my guitars and this amp
I'll pop the 250K Level back in and see how she goes.
Mines a 50w so hasn't the girthiness of the 100w. I think just a little more of the low/mid without losing the snarl and sing will be perfect.
I find I'm just rolling off a little on the guitar tone to "cream" things up.
I play a lot with keys and sax as well as show off bass players, so finding a space in the spectrum is really important.
Sounds like you would be happier with a 100W
FWIW..The low mids that the 100w gives you will always for me trump tweaking the pot values in a 50w..But maybe it will help you better find your spot in the mix!!

Good Luck!!
Tony
Yeah I put the 250K Level back in and left the 100K OD trigger.
So far it sounds good, amp still singing :) Thanks again.
User avatar
sepulchre
Posts: 923
Joined: Mon Dec 28, 2009 1:43 am
Location: Way out here (Logansport,In, USA)

Re: Big rehash - Strat into Dumble - what really works

Post by sepulchre »

I'm sure you've heard this, but it's from another (#102) thread.

http://ampgarage.com/forum/files/strat_clip_604.mp3
User avatar
Structo
Posts: 15446
Joined: Wed Oct 17, 2007 1:01 am
Location: Oregon

Re: Big rehash - Strat into Dumble - what really works

Post by Structo »

That was Gil's clip wasn't it?
Tom

Don't let that smoke out!
User avatar
sepulchre
Posts: 923
Joined: Mon Dec 28, 2009 1:43 am
Location: Way out here (Logansport,In, USA)

Re: Big rehash - Strat into Dumble - what really works

Post by sepulchre »

Yeah. I think it's a BF modded into a #102. It really sounds great IMHO but from what I can gather a #124 is generally better suited to Strats.

Btw, is there any intel about who the #124 was built for? Or maybe not their name but guitar used and playing style?
User avatar
renshen1957
Posts: 498
Joined: Fri Feb 20, 2009 8:13 am
Location: So-Cal

Re: Big rehash - Strat into Dumble - what really works

Post by renshen1957 »

talbany wrote:
vibratoking wrote:I've read ALL the threads regarding this. I mean ALL of them. I started with a 183 with 6L6 output section. Humbuckers sound great, Tele is good but not great, Strat is anemic. This is plugged into the normal input. I've been plugging my Strat and Tele into the FET input, which is a big improvement over the normal input but still not awesome like the humbucker into the normal.

Here is what I have tried based on previous threads:

- put slope resistor and mid cap on a switch. I've read great things about this mod, but I don't hear great things.
- classic tone stack vs skyliner. MAYBE a little improvement, but almost nothing in the big scheme of things.
- various high plate low plate and combination plates. MAYBE a little improvement, but almost nothing in the big scheme of things. These don't result in the big changes that I expected?
- bright switching on cleans and mid switching on OD. Helpful tweaks, but very small tangible results.
- various tweaks in the Dlator, but the Dlator really doesn't change the HB vs SC situation.

What I plan to try:
- bluesmaster PI with 12AX7
- bluesmaster tone stack with Gary's trick.
- AB763 PI with 12AT7
- AB763 clean channel with some sort of Dstyle OD

What I am missing with the strat and tele is chimey, lively cleans, like my 65 SR, and a elastic, fat, singing OD. The strat and tele really aren't that enjoyable to play with this amp. They are good but not great into the FET input.

My LPs have more chime than my strat or tele through the clean side. This isn't the case with these guitars on many other amps. I am starting to feel that my Dclone is a humbucker only machine. I've made many changes, but none of them has changed the basic SC character of this amp.

There just seems to be no SC magic in this amp. I'd appreciate any comments.
So on goes this story..Here is my take!!..Strat's and Tele's do not do the high gain saturated OD thing well in these amps you mention...There are always tradeoffs involved with cascaded (clean feeds OD) style amps..Humbuckers always do the high gain thing better..They tend to stay better focused on the low end and have a more prominent low mid sonic punch higher output and darker that works much better when amplified 100000 times. if you are one who likes to run the drive up Humbuckers are the way to go!!..
Lower output Strat and some Tele's don't do as well at higher gain settings..They tend to go loose and can get buzzy and harsh since they don't have the low mid output gain like a humbucker..If you keep the gain down and think of the OD as an extension of the clean (bigger with a bit more hair/crunch,compression) they seem to do just fine run like this!!..Some people here have had good results by running the input vol up high and keep the drive low and increase the OD vol and pus the mids..(D-lators can help too by allowing you to push the master)Modifying the amp might help you but will NEVER be the same as a hot PAF!!
I recently picked up a Gibson 339 and loaded in a JB (coil tap) on the bridge and made some compromise and works great for me!!..Perhaps you should look into a coil tap setup?
There I said it!!

For those more experienced builders out there please let me know if you have a different take on this!!

All The Best!!

Tony
Hi Tony,

Good overview on the subject. What is your take on P-90 pickups? Somewhat off topic, but a single coil pickup.

Best regards,

Steve
Every Tom, Dick, and Harry is named Steve
talbany
Posts: 4679
Joined: Tue Mar 28, 2006 5:03 am
Location: Dumbleland

Re: Big rehash - Strat into Dumble - what really works

Post by talbany »

Steve
Good question?...Let's take a teach the man to fish approach on this one..

To be straight here!!!.. When I think of (or reference Single coils) I am talking about traditional Fender Strat/Tele pickups (Low Alnicos and NOT overwound etc) There are so many different pickups manufactured today that are way out of spec ..Even now a day's some of the stock pickups in the newer guitars can be well off the reservation with respect to traditional...It seems every pickup guy has his/her idea of the perfect pickup...BUT what amp are they using,what sound are they going for,are they using much overdrive..On and on!!!!..

So with that said whenever you get a set of pickups with a higher gauss (stronger) magnets and over wound you notice a prominent mid push and darker.. The feel of the pickup changes too.. The stronger the field the faster the pickup responds altering feel..especially in the low end...Many players prefer this type of pickup when using multiple gain stages.(smoother tighter)
Generally an overwound pickup increases gain but at the expense of that top end sparkle we all like (especially in clean channel) A lower Alnico gives us a sweeter mids softer bass again more popular for clean use...
Most players who use allot of Gain prefer the stronger overwound pickups. The players who play mostly clean prefer the more traditional underwound (less output) style,,Since the ODS does both you have to be more selective at the guitar and pickups!!!

Most modern P90's are all over the place

You have to look at how the pickup was made and designed (same holds true with Tele Pickups and some Strat style made with stronger magnets and drastically overwound!!)
Since the ODS is a simple design the sound of that pickup is magnified without much color (along with your playing/technique) you have to strike a very delicate balance between clean and overdriven tones and at times be willing to compromise one for the other (clean OD)
Since we here are amp builders our immediate response is to start tweaking the Amp when in fact we should be looking at the guitar, what it is we want!! and of coarse what we want to say in our music!!...

Good Luck!!

Tony
Last edited by talbany on Mon Nov 11, 2013 12:18 am, edited 8 times in total.
" The psychics on my bench is the same as Dumble'"
10thTx
Posts: 1864
Joined: Sat Dec 30, 2006 1:13 am

Re: Big rehash - Strat into Dumble - what really works

Post by 10thTx »

you have to strike a very delicate balance between clean and overdriven tones and at times be willing to compromise one for the other (clean OD)
Totally well said! And I think clean OD is a very accurate and reasonable term.

Thanks for sharing your perspective! It is valued.

With respect, 10thtx
talbany
Posts: 4679
Joined: Tue Mar 28, 2006 5:03 am
Location: Dumbleland

Re: Big rehash - Strat into Dumble - what really works

Post by talbany »

Totally well said! And I think clean OD is a very accurate and reasonable term.
Actually I was going more for Clean vs OD there..

Tony
" The psychics on my bench is the same as Dumble'"
Post Reply