Cabinet made of OSB instead of pine
Moderators: pompeiisneaks, Colossal
- Raja_Kentut
- Posts: 65
- Joined: Fri Aug 11, 2023 9:57 am
- Location: Veitsbronn, Germany
1 others liked this
Cabinet made of OSB instead of pine
I would like to build a Fender Bassman cabinet with 4 x 10" speakers.
Keep to the original dimensions, but would prefer to use OSB boards (Beaver puke) instead of pine. (these very coarse chipboards e.g. https://www.obi.de/p/5799762/osb-3-verl ... -x-62-5-cm )
Does anyone here have sound experience with this material or any general comments on this material?
Keep to the original dimensions, but would prefer to use OSB boards (Beaver puke) instead of pine. (these very coarse chipboards e.g. https://www.obi.de/p/5799762/osb-3-verl ... -x-62-5-cm )
Does anyone here have sound experience with this material or any general comments on this material?
Nothing is better than an unexpected discovery that brings you happiness!
Re: Cabinet made of OSB instead of pine
How thick and what kind of joints do you plan to use?
Glenn
I solder better than I play.
I solder better than I play.
Re: Cabinet made of OSB instead of pine
Sound is greatly dependent of the wood used... OSB IMO is too dead material..once i had cab from mediapan in guitar cabinet.. the sound was awful. ![Neutral :|](./images/smilies/icon_neutral.gif)
![Neutral :|](./images/smilies/icon_neutral.gif)
Re: Cabinet made of OSB instead of pine
Bartel is taking too much care for the cabs... (i dont know if this is marketing for price boosting or real has some effect.. but..)
https://bartelamps.com/about/
https://bartelamps.com/about/
- Raja_Kentut
- Posts: 65
- Joined: Fri Aug 11, 2023 9:57 am
- Location: Veitsbronn, Germany
1 others liked this
Re: Cabinet made of OSB instead of pine
I planned to use 18mm thick.
the joints are glued and screwed together with a triangular strip inside as reinforcement
the joints are glued and screwed together with a triangular strip inside as reinforcement
Nothing is better than an unexpected discovery that brings you happiness!
Re: Cabinet made of OSB instead of pine
I agree with bepone about this being a dead sounding material. But if you're wanting a neutral cabinet it might be a good choice.
Your joint selection should be good. Personally I wouldn't even try nor trust finger joints or dovetails in this material.
I've made stereo speakers from plywood and MDF with good luck. Old school Tweeter/Midrange/woofer type.
IMO the OSB won't contribute much to the sound like a solid wood or high quality plywood would. It may be more of a hifi speaker than guitar cabinet. My opinion not based on any personal experience. That said I love my Thiele TS806 1x12 which is basically a tuned port (HIFI-ish)speaker with a EVM12L.
Your joint selection should be good. Personally I wouldn't even try nor trust finger joints or dovetails in this material.
I've made stereo speakers from plywood and MDF with good luck. Old school Tweeter/Midrange/woofer type.
IMO the OSB won't contribute much to the sound like a solid wood or high quality plywood would. It may be more of a hifi speaker than guitar cabinet. My opinion not based on any personal experience. That said I love my Thiele TS806 1x12 which is basically a tuned port (HIFI-ish)speaker with a EVM12L.
Glenn
I solder better than I play.
I solder better than I play.
- Reeltarded
- Posts: 9961
- Joined: Sat Feb 14, 2009 4:38 am
- Location: GA USA
2 others liked this
Re: Cabinet made of OSB instead of pine
I think OSB material will be rough to deal with in the future. It might go together ok, but once it starts vibrating or being moved around, it will tend to shed material until it's fragile enough to break like granola. It doesn't like to glue up because even if it sticks, the material is likely to shed the glued part with any torsion or shear force.
MDF is maybe a minimum density for a manufactured material. The stability is many times that of the OSB.
MDF is maybe a minimum density for a manufactured material. The stability is many times that of the OSB.
Signatures have a 255 character limit that I could abuse, but I am not Cecil B. DeMille.
Re: Cabinet made of OSB instead of pine
I would stay away from OSB. Marshall used it for some time but the cabinets are desintegrating with vibration over time (keep a vacuum cleaner handy)
MDF is heavy as lead and does not withstand stress on the edges very well
almost everybody uses 18mm/1/2" plywood today, if reinforced, you might get away with 15mm
usually people use birch plywood, there is a lighter variety made of poplar which can be hard to obtain in certain regions and is pricy
poplar needs reinforcement in any case as it is less strong than birch
MDF is heavy as lead and does not withstand stress on the edges very well
almost everybody uses 18mm/1/2" plywood today, if reinforced, you might get away with 15mm
usually people use birch plywood, there is a lighter variety made of poplar which can be hard to obtain in certain regions and is pricy
poplar needs reinforcement in any case as it is less strong than birch
- Raja_Kentut
- Posts: 65
- Joined: Fri Aug 11, 2023 9:57 am
- Location: Veitsbronn, Germany
2 others liked this
Re: Cabinet made of OSB instead of pine
thank you all for your thoughts.
I think I will not use OSB, the possible desintegration because of use/vibration really seems to be an issue…
I think I will not use OSB, the possible desintegration because of use/vibration really seems to be an issue…
Nothing is better than an unexpected discovery that brings you happiness!
Re: Cabinet made of OSB instead of pine
Just to note that rather than 1/2", I think the imperial equivalent of 18mm is 3/4"
![Smile :)](./images/smilies/icon_smile.gif)
My band:- http://www.youtube.com/user/RedwingBand
Re: Cabinet made of OSB instead of pine
The local mall carries a nice clear SPF from New Zealand.
No knots, good grain, makes good cabinets.
No knots, good grain, makes good cabinets.
Tube junkie that aspires to become a tri-state bidirectional buss driver.
Re: Cabinet made of OSB instead of pine
SOB as i like to call it. Does not hold fasteners. It doesn't glue well. It doesn't take joinery. I can't imagine any reason to use it for anything but sheathing on a house.
MDF is a better choice but it's heavy.
I've used 15mm Birch ply to build a 2x12 cab you could throw that thing out of the back of a moving truck
MDF is a better choice but it's heavy.
I've used 15mm Birch ply to build a 2x12 cab you could throw that thing out of the back of a moving truck
- Raja_Kentut
- Posts: 65
- Joined: Fri Aug 11, 2023 9:57 am
- Location: Veitsbronn, Germany
Re: Cabinet made of OSB instead of pine
I got a lot of it for free
![Laughing :lol:](./images/smilies/icon_lol.gif)
Nothing is better than an unexpected discovery that brings you happiness!
Re: Cabinet made of OSB instead of pine
That's pretty much its value.
Tube junkie that aspires to become a tri-state bidirectional buss driver.