I brought the amp up on my current limiter, seemed good so I bypassed the limiter and let it warm up fully. A few seconds after I took it out of standby there was a little pop through the speaker (like tapping a microphone) and no sound with a guitar plugged in. If I hit the strings hard I get a farty sound. A sine wave from my frequency gen comes through, but it's way too quiet. Oh, and it still red-plates in dual class mode

The new power tubes are biased OK, a touch colder than the old ones. I plugged my guitar into the effects return and it sounds perfect and loud, which verifies that the output section is functioning and I suppose the phase inverter as well. I put in all new preamp tubes and the issue persists. Now, I've done some probing with an oscilloscope and verified that the very first triode stage is working. Tomorrow I plan on finding where the signal goes from there with the scope and ensuring that each triode has plate voltage.
It is quite a complex amp and I have no hopes at getting a schematic, but I am confident I can figure it out if i take my time. To me it sounds like some part of the preamp is not biased or something. I know triodes are generally cathode biased for gain stages, and a lot of tweakability in more modern amps comes from switching cathode resistors and bypass caps, so perhaps the issue lies there. The amp has a few vactrols but I'm not exactly sure how to test those in circuit, as well as several small relays.
I will report back after I dig deeper, but I'm not expert by any stretch, so any ideas or advice is much appreciated!