Presence Circuit and Shunt Resistor
Moderators: pompeiisneaks, Colossal
-
- Posts: 178
- Joined: Wed May 31, 2017 11:11 pm
Presence Circuit and Shunt Resistor
I'd like to discuss the pros/cons and theory behind each of these three presence circuits. Amp is a 50-watt JCM800. But focusing just on presence.
I'm asking because I'm familiar with Arrangement 1 and 2. In #1, the 5K presence pot acts as the end of the PI tail. In #2, a 25K pot is used and the presence cap is in series to ground, rather than parallel. And a 4K7 resistor is used to end the tail. But what about Arrangement #3? At first glance it appears to be a mistake. As though someone wired it up by accidentally combining the first two. But... I want to give the amp builder the benefit of the doubt and assume maybe I'm just not understanding something and that the builder did it intentionally.
Arrangement 1
Arrangement 2
Arrangement 3
I'm asking because I'm familiar with Arrangement 1 and 2. In #1, the 5K presence pot acts as the end of the PI tail. In #2, a 25K pot is used and the presence cap is in series to ground, rather than parallel. And a 4K7 resistor is used to end the tail. But what about Arrangement #3? At first glance it appears to be a mistake. As though someone wired it up by accidentally combining the first two. But... I want to give the amp builder the benefit of the doubt and assume maybe I'm just not understanding something and that the builder did it intentionally.
Arrangement 1
Arrangement 2
Arrangement 3
Re: Presence Circuit and Shunt Resistor
#3 reduces the amount of feedback, and thus the amount of Presence when the pot is dimed. It increases the closed loop gain. The pot will still be scratchy. You could get some of the Presence back by changing to the 16 Ohm tap.
-
- Posts: 178
- Joined: Wed May 31, 2017 11:11 pm
Re: Presence Circuit and Shunt Resistor
Ok so essentially, it's simply reducing the overall range of the presence control from 5k to 4k7?
Re: Presence Circuit and Shunt Resistor
It's more like using a 2.5K pot.FourT6and2 wrote: ↑Tue Nov 01, 2022 12:08 am Ok so essentially, it's simply reducing the overall range of the presence control from 5k to 4k7?
-
- Posts: 178
- Joined: Wed May 31, 2017 11:11 pm
Re: Presence Circuit and Shunt Resistor
Alright thanks!
Seems like a weird choice then. Just stick with Arrangement 1 with 5K pot and you get the same result, but with more range if you want to dial it in?
But maybe the builder chose to do that to prevent the end user from making amp too bright and complaining.
Seems like a weird choice then. Just stick with Arrangement 1 with 5K pot and you get the same result, but with more range if you want to dial it in?
But maybe the builder chose to do that to prevent the end user from making amp too bright and complaining.
-
- Posts: 178
- Joined: Wed May 31, 2017 11:11 pm
Re: Presence Circuit and Shunt Resistor
Actually, wait... as you said, it would reduce NFB too
Re: Presence Circuit and Shunt Resistor
I discussed the argument in another forum.
I hope to be ok to link it here to give some more points of discussion here, otherwise please moderators remove the link: http://www.slocloneforums.com/viewtopic ... 24&t=14225
I hope to be ok to link it here to give some more points of discussion here, otherwise please moderators remove the link: http://www.slocloneforums.com/viewtopic ... 24&t=14225
-
- Posts: 178
- Joined: Wed May 31, 2017 11:11 pm
Re: Presence Circuit and Shunt Resistor
Thanks, I saw that. I'm having trouble visualizing which plots go with which actual circuit. I need a schematic to go with each one because I don't know what these mean:roberto wrote: ↑Tue Nov 01, 2022 8:24 pm I discussed the argument in another forum.
I hope to be ok to link it here to give some more points of discussion here, otherwise please moderators remove the link: http://www.slocloneforums.com/viewtopic ... 24&t=14225
- new 4k7 // 25k+100n: I guess this is Arrangement 2 (Marshall's 25K pot with 4k7 in parallel?)
- my 4k7 // 10k+100n; Same but with 10k pot instead of 25k?
- unused 4k7 // 5k+100n. What's this one mean? Unused 4k7?
Re: Presence Circuit and Shunt Resistor
I report the files here for other users too.
The 25k plus 100n presence pot that is in almost all post-80s amps works only on the very last part of the rotation.
I use 10k instead of 25k because it has a wider useful range (but I still prefer the old scratchy one).
The 25k plus 100n presence pot that is in almost all post-80s amps works only on the very last part of the rotation.
I use 10k instead of 25k because it has a wider useful range (but I still prefer the old scratchy one).
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
Re: Presence Circuit and Shunt Resistor
Some more plots:
Old scratchy ones:
- 5k lin pot fully CW with sweep on 100n 220n 330n 470n 680n 1u;
- 5k lin pot with 680n;
Non-scratchy ones:
- 4k7 plus 5k lin pot with 680n;
- 4k7 plus 10k lin pot with 680n;
- 4k7 plus 25k lin pot with 680n;
Old scratchy ones:
- 5k lin pot fully CW with sweep on 100n 220n 330n 470n 680n 1u;
- 5k lin pot with 680n;
Non-scratchy ones:
- 4k7 plus 5k lin pot with 680n;
- 4k7 plus 10k lin pot with 680n;
- 4k7 plus 25k lin pot with 680n;
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
- martin manning
- Posts: 13355
- Joined: Sun Jul 06, 2008 12:43 am
- Location: 39°06' N 84°30' W
Re: Presence Circuit and Shunt Resistor
I prefer the old scratchy version too. Besides the improved sweep, and the ability to eliminate the bypass capacitor completely, the older circuit brings the high frequency boost in from the high end, rather than across the range.
Re: Presence Circuit and Shunt Resistor
I seem to prefer the original DC on pot version with NMV amps such as JTM45, whereas with an overdrive preamp 2204 based build, that just didn’t sound right, the later version with a 5k pot sounded more natural at every setting and had the best range of control.
Thanks for the plots demonstrating why that might be the case, roberto
Thanks for the plots demonstrating why that might be the case, roberto
My band:- http://www.youtube.com/user/RedwingBand
-
- Posts: 178
- Joined: Wed May 31, 2017 11:11 pm
Re: Presence Circuit and Shunt Resistor
How are those all wired up? Cap in series or parallel?
- martin manning
- Posts: 13355
- Joined: Sun Jul 06, 2008 12:43 am
- Location: 39°06' N 84°30' W
Re: Presence Circuit and Shunt Resistor
Old Scratchy is your Type 1, non-scratchy is your Type 2.