Corrective filter in 4xEL84 amp
Moderators: pompeiisneaks, Colossal
Corrective filter in 4xEL84 amp
Hi,
I wanted to try a corrective filter (As Seen in RCA in my TW Rocket clone, which has a less than optimal OT.
A 10k/5W in series with a 2.2n across the OT primaries can be found in the Dr. Z Carmen Ghia and Suhr Badger 18, so I want to give it a go.
The original article says that the resistance should be about 1.3x the plate-to-plate impedance, which is about 10k for an typical 8k primary (assumed to be in both the aforementioned 2xEL84 amps). I have a 4K primary with 4x EL84s, so I'm thinking 5k would be fine.
My questions is about how to "size-up" the 2.2n for the two extra tubes in parallel. Is it necessary? Would I simply double the capacitance to keep the same filter?
Thanks for any help.
I wanted to try a corrective filter (As Seen in RCA in my TW Rocket clone, which has a less than optimal OT.
A 10k/5W in series with a 2.2n across the OT primaries can be found in the Dr. Z Carmen Ghia and Suhr Badger 18, so I want to give it a go.
The original article says that the resistance should be about 1.3x the plate-to-plate impedance, which is about 10k for an typical 8k primary (assumed to be in both the aforementioned 2xEL84 amps). I have a 4K primary with 4x EL84s, so I'm thinking 5k would be fine.
My questions is about how to "size-up" the 2.2n for the two extra tubes in parallel. Is it necessary? Would I simply double the capacitance to keep the same filter?
Thanks for any help.
Re: Corrective filter in 4xEL84 amp
Is that what it's called in the RCA book? I recall several discussions over at el34world and AX84 - google "conjunctive filter" and you'll get some good hits.
Re: Corrective filter in 4xEL84 amp
Yeah, I've heard it referred to as both. I've read all the threads I can find, but not a simple answer to my question unfortunately. Thanks.
-
- Posts: 257
- Joined: Tue Apr 27, 2010 4:39 am
- Location: Everett Wa.
Re: Corrective filter in 4xEL84 amp
Gaz the guitar player magazine article had what your looking for, i will try to find it.
Bill
Bill
Last edited by Tone Lover on Fri Nov 15, 2013 3:00 am, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Corrective filter in 4xEL84 amp
(deleted)
Last edited by matt h on Fri Mar 27, 2015 2:22 am, edited 2 times in total.
- Leo_Gnardo
- Posts: 2584
- Joined: Thu Sep 27, 2012 1:33 pm
- Location: Dogpatch-on-Hudson
Re: Corrective filter in 4xEL84 amp
I'm thinkin' that such a zobel could be applied at other spots in the amp, such as a Vox "cut" control across the plates of the output drive tube, or even early in the chain, after all what's a tone control in a guitar?
In the case of having this "corrective" filter applied across the primary of an OT = output tube plates, one has to wonder if it's there to damp ultrasonic ringing of the OT. If the intention was to simply affect the tone, there are other spots in the circuit where that could be done, and employ components that need not have to stand up to the high voltages across the OT primary.
In the case of having this "corrective" filter applied across the primary of an OT = output tube plates, one has to wonder if it's there to damp ultrasonic ringing of the OT. If the intention was to simply affect the tone, there are other spots in the circuit where that could be done, and employ components that need not have to stand up to the high voltages across the OT primary.
down technical blind alleys . . .
- Reeltarded
- Posts: 9964
- Joined: Sat Feb 14, 2009 4:38 am
- Location: GA USA
Re: Corrective filter in 4xEL84 amp
Zobel? So that is what i am doing when i dump treble to ground with a cap and a resistor. Zobeling?
Signatures have a 255 character limit that I could abuse, but I am not Cecil B. DeMille.
Re: Corrective filter in 4xEL84 amp
Thanks, Bill, I see now in the Maven Peal article. It makes sense that the resistor needs to be smaller to accommodate the extra parallel tubes, and the simple RC filter just needs to be adjusted for that. So it looks like your intuition was right, matt h.
The amp in question has VVR on the output tubes and PI, and at very low setting gets this annoying swirly fizz on top of everything when the gain is cranked up. The amp sounds normal at less than whisper volumes.
I did notice a small leading edge on the scope, but nothing that looks fuzzy like a parasitic, and it only appears at the output, therefore no low pass filter before the output get rid of it.
The amp in question has VVR on the output tubes and PI, and at very low setting gets this annoying swirly fizz on top of everything when the gain is cranked up. The amp sounds normal at less than whisper volumes.
I did notice a small leading edge on the scope, but nothing that looks fuzzy like a parasitic, and it only appears at the output, therefore no low pass filter before the output get rid of it.
Re: Corrective filter in 4xEL84 amp
Gaz,
I hope Ian (Gingertube) jumps in on this thread. IIRC he may have been involved in a fairly in depth filter discussion over at the now defunct powerscaling.com site.
BTW, regarding the swirly PI, I'm guessing you are over driving it. As you are scaling the PI down, the signal feeding it needs to be decreased as well. Think of an open window getting smaller and smaller as it is closed, while the signal remains the same size. In fact, the feeding signal may even increase as the power amp is unloaded.
I hope Ian (Gingertube) jumps in on this thread. IIRC he may have been involved in a fairly in depth filter discussion over at the now defunct powerscaling.com site.
BTW, regarding the swirly PI, I'm guessing you are over driving it. As you are scaling the PI down, the signal feeding it needs to be decreased as well. Think of an open window getting smaller and smaller as it is closed, while the signal remains the same size. In fact, the feeding signal may even increase as the power amp is unloaded.
Re: Corrective filter in 4xEL84 amp
Thanks, John. I would be great to hear Ian's 2c. I've actually tried a few things to pin down the problem already...
First I added a large grid stop to the PI, but that didn't help. Next I added a pre-PI master to dial down the signal, but it didn't get rid of what I was describing. I also tried just scaling the output tubes, but that made the swirly fizz even worse.
I'm pretty sure the leading edge on the waveform is unrelated, and what I'm hearing is just the result of a lot of overdrive (especially EL84 overdrive (at really low volumes.) Seems like the corrective filter could kill two birds with one stone, however.
FWIW, I've played around with the lead dress, and it is really tidy in the output stage with short grid wires and 10k stoppers on the power tubes. Nothing I did affected the sound, so I've ruled out all the obvious wiring stuff.
First I added a large grid stop to the PI, but that didn't help. Next I added a pre-PI master to dial down the signal, but it didn't get rid of what I was describing. I also tried just scaling the output tubes, but that made the swirly fizz even worse.
I'm pretty sure the leading edge on the waveform is unrelated, and what I'm hearing is just the result of a lot of overdrive (especially EL84 overdrive (at really low volumes.) Seems like the corrective filter could kill two birds with one stone, however.
FWIW, I've played around with the lead dress, and it is really tidy in the output stage with short grid wires and 10k stoppers on the power tubes. Nothing I did affected the sound, so I've ruled out all the obvious wiring stuff.
- Leo_Gnardo
- Posts: 2584
- Joined: Thu Sep 27, 2012 1:33 pm
- Location: Dogpatch-on-Hudson
Re: Corrective filter in 4xEL84 amp
Yep. Keep it up and you may win the zobel prize. Or igzobel prize. Depending...Reeltarded wrote:Zobel? So that is what i am doing when i dump treble to ground with a cap and a resistor. Zobeling?
For extra credit add an inductor.
If you've seen any of JBL's latest passive crossovers, they're paved with them - "correction circuits", lots of little coils. Thank heaven for little coils.
down technical blind alleys . . .
Re: Corrective filter in 4xEL84 amp
Gaz, Sounds like you have approached it logically. I remember working on a 2204 build that had the swirlies that I could never fully get rid of. It may be related to filtering / grounding. I remember Kevin O'Connor saying that power scaling exposes all weaknesses in grounding.
Re: Corrective filter in 4xEL84 amp
I remember Paul Ruby did a article about buzzies or fizzie, in the 18w amps.
This PDF shows scope shots and good info how to cure this stuff.
This PDF shows scope shots and good info how to cure this stuff.
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
Tom
Don't let that smoke out!
Don't let that smoke out!
- randalp3000
- Posts: 667
- Joined: Mon Jan 09, 2012 11:11 pm
- Location: Holland Michigan
- Contact:
Re: Corrective filter in 4xEL84 amp
thanks for sharing that article, I have a pretty well known booteek amp that looks like this on the output and have been wondering where to start with it. Lifting the cathode bypass cap helps considerably. It is also biased super cold but didn't make much difference with a more appropriate cathode resistor.Structo wrote:I remember Paul Ruby did a article about buzzies or fizzie, in the 18w amps.
This PDF shows scope shots and good info how to cure this stuff.
[IMG577]http://i1233.photobucket.com/albums/ff388/randalp3000/amps/IMAG0481_zps009f95dd.jpg[/img]
ugly isn't it?
Re: Corrective filter in 4xEL84 amp
My problem isn't the paul ruby thing. It's just a matter of all the really high harmonics becoming more present at very low volumes with the scaling. I'm also using Merlin's grounding to a "T" (basically the same as Kevin's "galactic ground")
I tried the the corrective filter and it definitely fixes it, by simply evening them out to the level of the other frequencies. Now, however, the very low volumes are kind unusable because they are so smooth. I guess I can't have my .1W and play it too.
I tried the the corrective filter and it definitely fixes it, by simply evening them out to the level of the other frequencies. Now, however, the very low volumes are kind unusable because they are so smooth. I guess I can't have my .1W and play it too.